How to Follow Up With a Headhunter: The 7-Week Cadence That Gets You a Call
Kristof Schoenaerts
Most executives email a headhunter once, maybe twice, and give up by week 2.
They assume the message was wrong. Usually the email was fine and the consultant's calendar was full.
Here's what it looks like from my side of the desk. I want to reply to most senior candidates who reach out properly. Your email arrives, I plan to come back to it, and 3 weeks later it's buried under hundreds of newer messages.
The candidates who end up on my calendar are the ones who follow up patiently, for 7 weeks.
Get the first email right
A follow-up only works if the first email deserves one. 4 rules.
1. Sound like a peer
A senior executive who sounds employed, confident and curious about the market reads completely differently from a stressed candidate. Headhunters reply to the first one.
2. Name 2 things: your career and the industry
Every message should cover where your career is heading and what's happening in the industry. The consultant gets market insight, you get a conversation. That's the win/win.
3. Ask for 15 minutes
Frame it as "where my career is heading" or "my career options". "I'm looking for my next opportunity" makes you sound like an applicant.
4. Keep it to 3 or 4 sentences
The consultant reads it on a phone between meetings. A long email gets filed under "later", and later rarely comes.
A few more mechanics:
Short, specific subject line that matches their practice
No attachments on first contact
Your current or most recent role, scope and industry, in 2 sentences
Under 100 words in total
Here's the shape:
Send it by email
Senior headhunters check their email far more often than their LinkedIn inbox. Find the consultant's address on the firm's website. Keep InMail as a backup for when email and a connection request both fail.
3 lines that get deleted on sight
"I am passionate, results-oriented, and actively exploring new opportunities."
"I saw you work in executive search and thought we should connect."
"Please find my CV attached."
The fix: the 7-week follow-up cadence
Once the first email is out, follow up once a week for 7 weeks. The rules:
Same thread every time. Never start a new subject line.
Under 50 words per message. Same warmth, same short ask.
A new opening sentence each week, so the messages don't feel templated. A recent deal in their sector works. So does a market move you noticed.
Never count your follow-ups out loud. "This is my fourth email" reads as pressure.
Never imply they're ignoring you. "Just checking you saw this" puts them on the defensive.
A confident peer follows up the same way the tenth time as the first.
A week 3 follow-up might look like this:
Week 7: the exit message
In week 7, say you'll stop following up. Say the door stays open from your side and that you hope your paths cross.
It takes the pressure off both of you. And it often triggers a reply.
Why this works
Each follow-up gives the consultant another chance to reply in a week when their calendar finally has room. 7 weeks gives them 7 chances.
Executives who stop at week 2 never reach that moment.
Your one task this week
Pick 3 consultants you emailed in the last 2 months who never replied.
Reply in the same thread, under 50 words, with a fresh opening line and the same 15-minute ask. Then put a weekly reminder in your calendar for the next 6 weeks.
Your next executive role will most likely start with a conversation you had to chase. Make sure you're still chasing in week 7.
If you want the target list and the outreach built for you, my one-month coaching program includes a LinkedIn profile rewrite, an outreach strategy, 4 private calls, a network activation plan and a list of executive search consultants who cover your industry, level and target markets.
Explore the coaching program →
Subscribe to Job Search Unlocked → for the recruiter's side of the executive job search, twice a week.
A recruiter’s perspective, in your inbox.
Practical insights on LinkedIn and executive hiring, without the pressure to become an influencer.