Why "Please Keep Me in Mind" Hurts You on a Headhunter Call (and What to Ask Instead)

Kristof Schoenaerts

The call with the headhunter went well. You walked through your career, answered every question, and ended with the line almost every executive uses.

"Please keep me in mind for future opportunities."

When I hear that line as a search consultant, my reaction is always the same. This person doesn't understand how we work.

There is no secret list

Many executives believe headhunters keep a confidential list of strong candidates and pull from it when a new role comes in. There's no such list.

Every search is built from scratch. When a new mandate lands, the longlist gets rebuilt from current data. Nothing from the previous search's longlist carries over automatically.

Think about what a "good CFO list" would need to work. It would have to be sliced into thousands of sub-categories: IPO experience, French-speaking, sector, company size, turnaround versus growth. Each entry would need current availability, compensation expectations, notice period and mobility, kept fresh in real time.

That's a fantasy database. The real one is LinkedIn Recruiter, and every new search starts with a fresh search there.

What brings you back into a search

2 things decide whether a consultant calls you about the next role.

1. The database

When I start a mandate, I map the market in LinkedIn Recruiter using the job titles, industries and locations in the brief. If your profile doesn't match those searches, the call you had last year doesn't help. You're not on the longlist.

2. The call itself

LinkedIn Recruiter doesn't tell me who to call first, who will pick up, or who is worth stretching a brief for at 80% fit. The conversation does.

If you gave real value on the call, I'll think of you for roles that are close without being perfect. I already know you're sharp, focused and easy to work with.

So the call matters. "Please keep me in mind" just wastes the most useful minute of it.

How to run a 20-minute headhunter call

A headhunter call is a business conversation between 2 professionals in the same industry. It works when both sides get something out of it.

Open by asking how they want to run it

"How do you want to approach this call?" Very few executives ask this. It tells the consultant you respect their time and their process.

Cover your last role in 5 minutes or less

3 points: what you were hired to do (scope, geography, team, revenue), what you delivered (2 or 3 results with numbers), and a clean, one-sentence reason why you're in the market.

Share something they don't know

Bring one piece of market intelligence. A competitor hiring aggressively, a regulatory shift, a company restructuring before it announces anything. This is where you become useful to the consultant, beyond being a candidate.

Close with 4 questions

These replace "please keep me in mind".

  1. "Who in the industry do you recommend I talk to?" This opens warm introductions and a second layer of network.

  2. "Which companies do you think fit my profile best?" You get market positioning data from someone who sees dozens of mandates.

  3. "What would you recommend for an efficient job search at my level?" It taps their expertise, and most consultants enjoy answering it.

  4. "What can I help you with?" This one turns the conversation around. Consultants remember the people who ask it.

Lines to drop from every headhunter call

  • "Let me walk you through my career"

  • "I'm open to anything"

  • "Do you have anything for me?"

  • "I want to put myself on your radar"

  • "I left because of politics" (or a difficult boss, or a toxic culture)

  • "Please keep me in mind for future opportunities"

Each one makes you sound like a job seeker asking for help.

Your one task this week

Before your next headhunter call, write 2 things on one page.

First, one piece of market intelligence from your sector that the consultant probably hasn't heard yet. Second, the 4 closing questions, word for word.

Keep the page next to you on the call. If you catch yourself starting to say "keep me in mind", read the next question instead.

Your next executive role will come from a search that starts from zero. Make sure you're findable when it starts, and memorable from the last call.

If you want help preparing for headhunter calls, my one-month coaching program includes a LinkedIn profile rewrite, an outreach strategy, 4 private calls, a network activation plan and a list of executive search consultants who cover your industry, level and target markets.

Explore the coaching program →

Subscribe to Job Search Unlocked → for the recruiter's side of the executive job search, twice a week.

A recruiter’s perspective, in your inbox.

Practical insights on LinkedIn and executive hiring, without the pressure to become an influencer.

Job Search Unlocked

© 2026 Job Search Unlocked. Founded by Kristof Schoenaerts.

© 2026 Job Search Unlocked. Founded by Kristof Schoenaerts.